Chaska Herald - American Idol: Sap central - Comments

I WAS ROBBED!

txaggie94 — Wed, 25 Apr 2007 21:04:31 -0500

I WAS ROBBED!

I sat there, waiting for someone to get kicked off, and they KEPT EVERYONE! It was really Jordin's turn to go - her off-key American Prayer vocals sealed the deal for me.

-Katie

Yes! I almost fell over when

ztraces — Wed, 25 Apr 2007 13:33:13 -0500

Yes! I almost fell over when Ryan mentioned that Bono was the mentor this week. But where was he and what kind of games is the show playing with me?? *sniff*

In complete agreement on the

ChicChick — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 22:20:06 -0500

In complete agreement on the "no more inspirational sap." Snore. (Although I did actually vote tonight since it apparently is for a good cause, so I'm not that black-hearted.) Let's get to the point where the contestants get to pick the songs they want without a silly theme. I want more Beatboxing Blake!! Loved his performance tonight. Lovely. And I loved Melinda's performance. I love her singing, I love her attitude, I love her.

But to continue on my crotchedy, curmudgeonly streak, in the words of Nanny McPhee, I'm so over Kiki and Jordin. I agree with Simon, Kiki always seems to be shouting now, where before her voice was more, I think the word I'm looking for is, "swelly." And Jordin is way too 17 for me. It's like revisiting Diana DiGarmo, albeit with more talent. I'll concede she's a frontrunner for Idol champ, but I don't have to like her.

And where was the great mentor Bono tonight? Didn't I hear Ryan say at the beginning that Bono was the weekly mentor? Or did I just hear him wrong and I'm making this up?

American Idol: Sap central

Mollee Francisco — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 21:05:42 -0500

How can I say I never want to hear a night of inspirational songs again on American Idol without seeming like a heartless wretch?